Tavolo.  Table.  Tafel. Mesa. Tabl.

Whichever language you choose, we have been tasked with sketching six tables, in position – using the ergonomics sketches from previous – all of a different design and in keeping with the Orangebox / BBC way.

 

Sticking with the techniques I have been using this term, I kept with the digital sketching.  I don’t find it easier than pen and paper – in fact I find both hard, but the unnatural feeling of the graphics tablet is difficult to learn – but find the ability to keep the sketches digital, quick tracing of a desired design and an unlimited source of colours is a big bonus.  I will persist with this.

As can be seen, I went for more than 6 designs.  Many are sketches of shapes or mechanics of how the product would work.  Almost all are in side-on position, with some placed in-position over the earlier ergonomics outlines.

 

Which do I favour?  None?  Maybe.  

 

Public Vote

 

With the designs in hand, we were to present these to a group of 5 other peers to discuss our designs, citing positives and negatives; with the final goal being to find a group consensus for two favoured designs.  The group gave me some positive responses to my designs – they are a kind group – but clearly focused one in particular and elements of others.

 

temp-tables1
The Chosen Two

Analysis

 

This task has been tricky for me.  Sketching is not my forte, nor is impartiality.  If I find a design I like, I am all too quick to dispose of previous ideas and think this the best.  Until the next one comes along, and then I think this is the best in the world.  I need to be more open to criticism, both from myself and others.  I am all too quick to decide this is the best design, that it cannot be improved and my job is done.  I think I have exhausted all modifications to the design and I am a genius, drop mic, walk off.  Having the group choose a design certainly helped to overcome this, but what happens when they choose my favourite?  If I step away from the design and look at something else entirely, and then return a while later, hopefully this change of perspective will help.

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s